a licensed therapist dedicated to helping individuals and families heal from religious trauma, navigate faith transitions, and embrace meaningful life changes. My approach is grounded in compassion, evidence-based practices like DBT and EMDR, and a deep understanding of the unique challenges my clients face. I believe in creating a space where you feel seen, supported, and empowered to reconnect with your inner compass.

By Mellissa Hill, MS, LPC, Inner Compass Counseling & Consultation
Picture a 13-year-old girl on a Sunday morning. She got her two little brothers dressed. She packed the diaper bag. She found the missing church shoe. Mom is worn out. Dad left early for meetings. In the hallway at church, an older woman pats her arm and says, “You’re such a good little mother.”
She smiles. She feels proud. And she learns something she will carry for years: I am loved because I am useful.
I hear stories like this all the time. Many of my clients in Arizona and Utah grew up in big, religious families. LDS (Mormon), Catholic, non-denominational. They were the oldest. Or the oldest girl. Or the “responsible one.” Now they are adults who can’t rest. They can’t say no. And they often can’t tell what they feel.
There’s a word for this. It’s called parentification.
Parentification happens when a child takes on adult jobs in the family. These jobs go past normal chores. The child starts doing what a parent would usually do.
Researchers sort these jobs into two kinds (Hooper, 2007; Dariotis et al., 2023):
Instrumental parentification is the practical stuff. Cooking dinner. Changing diapers. Getting little kids ready for school. Putting them to bed.
Emotional parentification is the heart stuff. Comforting a sad or stressed parent. Keeping the peace. Being a parent’s best friend or secret-keeper. Feeling like it’s your job to keep everyone okay.
In IFS, we would say a part of the child steps into a protector role. That part decides it is safer to help than to need help. It does this even when it costs the child their own growth and health.
Here’s what matters most. Research shows that emotional parentification tends to cause more harm than the practical kind (Dariotis et al., 2023). Changing diapers is hard work. But being in charge of a parent’s feelings is a weight no child is built to carry.
I want to be clear. Big families are not the problem. Many big families are full of love, fun, and closeness. Kids helping out at home can be a good thing.
But here’s the math. More kids means more needs. Parents only have two hands. In many big families, the older kids become a second set of hands. Often it’s the older girls.
Research backs this up. A national study of how teens spend their time looked at teens caring for younger siblings. Girls did more of the hands-on care and talking. Boys more often played. That matches how many moms and dads split the work (Wikle, Jensen, & Hoagland, 2018). Another review found that girls tend to give more hours of family care than boys as they get older (East, 2010).
So the oldest daughter often isn’t just babysitting. She’s practicing being a mom. At 11. At 12. At 14.
This is where religion comes in. I want to be careful and honest here. Very little research looks at parentification and high-control religion together. What I share in this section comes from what I see in my office. I’m connecting it to what the research says about parentification in general.
In many high-control religious homes, a few things stack up at once:
Put those together and you get a child doing an adult’s job. And the whole community calls it righteous.
That last part is key. One of the biggest factors in whether parentification hurts is whether it feels fair to the child. In a study of 783 college students, feeling that it was unfair helped explain the link between parentification and later mental health symptoms (Jankowski, Hooper, Sandage, & Hannah, 2013).
But how does a child spot unfairness when her parents, her church, and God all seem to agree she is doing the right thing? Most of the time, she can’t. So the hurt goes underground.
So what happens inside a child who takes on this role? Here’s what I see, along with what the research supports.
She stops noticing her own needs. When your job is to watch everyone else, you stop checking in with yourself. Many of my clients tell me they truly don’t know what they feel. They don’t notice they’re tired until they crash. That isn’t a flaw. It was a survival skill.
Love gets tied to being useful. A child learns, “I matter when I help.” As an adult, that can turn into people-pleasing and over-giving. She takes care of everyone but never lets anyone take care of her.
Angry parts get sent away. In IFS terms, there are often parts that feel resentful about all of this. Parts that want to shout, “What about me?” In a high-control religious home, anger is often treated as sin. So those parts get shamed and pushed away. They don’t disappear. Later they may show up as burnout, depression, or anger that seems to come out of nowhere.
Her body pays a price. Living on high alert, always responsible, is stressful. Scientist Bruce McEwen called the long-term wear and tear of stress on the body “allostatic load” (McEwen, 1998). When the stress system never gets to turn off, health can suffer over time.
The effects can last for years. A meta-analysis found that childhood parentification was linked to mental health struggles in adulthood (Hooper, DeCoster, White, & Voltz, 2011).
This part surprises a lot of my clients. Parentification can also build real strengths.
A big review of 95 studies found that parentified kids can take different paths. Some flounder. Some are resilient. Some even thrive. The difference often comes down to support, resources, and whether the child sees their role as fair (Dariotis et al., 2023).
A study of Mexican American teens found that caring for younger siblings was linked to bigger goals for school, more kindness toward others, and more interest in school. But it was also tied to missing more school (East & Hamill, 2013). Both things were true at the same time.
Another study found that resilience was the strongest predictor of growth after childhood parentification (Hooper, Marotta, & Lanthier, 2008).
Many of my parentified clients are amazing leaders. They stay calm in a crisis. They can read a room in seconds. They get things done. Those strengths are real. But they often came at a cost. You get to keep the strengths without paying that cost forever.
Not always. Lots of kids help out at home, and that can be healthy.
But it can become religious trauma when the load is too heavy, it lasts for years, and religion is used to make it feel holy and non-negotiable. Researchers describe religious and spiritual abuse as a misuse of power in a religious setting that causes both mental and spiritual harm (Ellis et al., 2022). When a child is told that giving up her own needs is what God wants, it can hurt both her mind and her spirit.
This connects to something I’ve written about before. In How High-Control Religion Teaches Emotional Illiteracy, I talk about how kids in these homes often never learn to name their feelings. Parentification makes that even harder. If your job is to manage everyone else’s emotions, there’s no room left for your own.
This is one reason I love IFS for parentification. In IFS, we don’t try to get rid of the caretaking part. That part worked so hard. It kept the family going. It deserves thanks.
Instead, we help that part see it doesn’t have to work alone anymore. We get to know the angry parts that were sent away, and we listen to what they were protecting. We care for the younger parts that never got to just be little. And slowly, you start to notice your own body, your own needs, and your own feelings.
Healing doesn’t mean you stop caring about people. It means you finally get to be one of the people you care about.
Here are a few questions to sit with:
I practice in Arizona, and I work with a lot of people connected to Utah too. Between LDS wards, Catholic parishes, and non-denominational churches in both states, big families and strong religious roles are part of daily life for many people here.
If you’re in Gilbert, Mesa, Chandler, Tempe, Queen Creek, or anywhere in Arizona or Utah, and you were the “little mom” or the “second dad” in your family, please hear this: you are not selfish for having needs. You were a child. You deserved to be one.
If guilt and “doing it right” still run your life, you may also relate to our post on Can Religious Trauma Cause OCD or Scrupulosity? And if you’re still sorting out what counts as trauma, start with Religious Trauma vs. Church Hurt.
Our team at Inner Compass Counseling currently has two clinicians with openings: Jessica Dawson, LPC and Ashley Kirkpatrick, LAC. Both work closely with clients healing from religious trauma and family patterns across Arizona and Utah. You can view their schedules and book a session here.
Every clinician on our team is supervised or consulted by me directly. That means when you sit down with any member of our staff, even our newest clinicians, you also get the benefit of my years of experience with religious trauma and family healing. You are never getting “less than.” You are getting our whole team behind you.
You spent your childhood taking care of everyone else. It’s your turn now.
Want more posts like this on religious trauma, family patterns, and healing? Subscribe to our newsletter here.
designed by SEPTEMBER STUDIO
TERMS & CONDITIONS
PRIVACY POLICY
Copyright 2020 INNER COMPASS COUNSELING & CONSULTATION
@mellissaperrytherapy
633 E Ray Road
Gilbert, AZ 85296-4200
602-633-4496
Inner Compass is a licensed mental health haven in Gilbert, Arizona for individuals, couples, families, and teens who are navigating life’s transitions and trauma. Offering religious trauma therapy, trauma therapy, and EMDR therapy.
Inner Compass is a licensed mental health haven in Gilbert, Arizona for individuals, couples, families, and teens who are navigating life’s transitions and trauma.
Be the first to comment