a licensed therapist dedicated to helping individuals and families heal from religious trauma, navigate faith transitions, and embrace meaningful life changes. My approach is grounded in compassion, evidence-based practices like DBT and EMDR, and a deep understanding of the unique challenges my clients face. I believe in creating a space where you feel seen, supported, and empowered to reconnect with your inner compass.
By Mellissa Perry Hill, Inner Compass Counseling
A client once told me, half laughing and half crying, “I prayed over a pack of gum at the gas station. Not a blessing on the food. A prayer asking if it was okay to buy it.” She was 34 years old. She knew it didn’t make sense. She did it anyway, because the one time she skipped it, the dread sat on her chest for the rest of the day.
If that story made you wince because it sounds a little too familiar, keep reading.
I work with a lot of people in Arizona and Utah who grew up in high-control religion. LDS (Mormon), Catholic, non-denominational, and everything in between. And over and over, I see the same pattern. The religious trauma is there. And right on top of it, sometimes woven all the way through it, is OCD. Specifically, a kind of OCD called scrupulosity.
So let’s talk about it. Can religious trauma actually cause OCD? What is scrupulosity? And why does the “repentance process” so many of us were taught look so much like an OCD cycle?
Scrupulosity is sometimes called “religious OCD” or “moral OCD.” It’s not a separate diagnosis. It’s a theme that OCD can latch onto.
Like all OCD, it has two parts:
Obsessions are unwanted thoughts, images, or doubts that show up uninvited and feel awful. With scrupulosity, they sound like: Did I just sin? Did I think something blasphemous? Did I really mean that prayer? Am I going to hell? Is God angry with me?
Compulsions are the things you do to make the anxiety go away. Praying again. Confessing again. Re-reading scripture “until it feels right.” Asking your mom, your spouse, or your bishop, “Do you think I’m okay?” for the fifteenth time.
Researchers at the University of Pennsylvania built a questionnaire to measure this, called the Penn Inventory of Scrupulosity. When they tested it, they found that scrupulosity clustered around two main fears: fear of having sinned and fear of punishment from God (Abramowitz et al., 2002). Those two fears probably sound familiar to anyone who grew up being told God was always watching.
Here’s the key thing to understand. In a healthy faith, prayer and repentance bring peace. In scrupulosity, they bring peace for about five minutes. Then the doubt comes back, louder. Researchers describe it this way: compulsions keep scrupulosity going because the relief is short and the doubt is never fully answered (Abramowitz & Jacoby, 2014). Religion is full of things no one can ever be 100% certain about. And OCD hates uncertainty.
I want to be honest with you here, because you deserve honesty and not hype.
OCD has many roots. Genetics play a role. Brain wiring plays a role. Stress plays a role. No single study has proven that religious trauma, by itself, causes OCD. That research simply hasn’t been done yet.
But here is what the research does show, and why I believe religious trauma is one of the roots I see most often in my office:
Trauma and OCD are connected. A meta-analysis pulling together many studies found that people with a history of trauma tend to have more severe obsessive-compulsive symptoms (Miller & Brock, 2017). And a 2025 study of people directly exposed to a major traumatic event found that about a quarter of them developed brand-new OCD symptoms afterward. The authors called it the first direct evidence that trauma can trigger OCD, not just make it worse (Kalanthroff et al., 2025).
Emotional abuse is linked to religious obsessions specifically. This one stopped me in my tracks. A 2025 systematic review looked at 22 studies and over 5,600 adults with OCD. Childhood emotional abuse and neglect were tied to more severe OCD, and to more religious, sexual, and aggressive obsessions (Baldini et al., 2025). Think about what emotional abuse often looks like in a high-control home: shame, fear of being cast out, love that feels conditional on obedience.
Trauma seems to create a specific kind of compulsion. A 2026 study of 662 adults in intensive OCD treatment found something researchers called an “Absolution” factor. It only showed up in people who had a trauma history. These were compulsions aimed at getting rid of guilt, obligation, or punishment (Pinciotti et al., 2026). Absolution. The researchers used a religious word to describe what traumatized brains do. I don’t think that’s an accident.
Religious abuse is real trauma. A large review of the research defined religious and spiritual abuse as a misuse of power in a religious setting that causes both psychological and spiritual harm (Ellis et al., 2022). That’s the trauma. And trauma is fertile ground for OCD.
So my clinical view is this: religious trauma may not be the only cause of OCD. But for a lot of people I work with, it planted the seed, watered it, and then handed them a ritual to perform every time it sprouted.
This is the part I really want you to sit with.
In most settings, if someone prays 20 times a day out of fear, the people around them might notice and gently ask if they’re okay. In high-control religion, that same person gets called devout. Faithful. An example.
The compulsions don’t just go unnoticed. They get praised.
Here are some of the patterns I hear about all the time:
Researchers have a name for one of the thinking traps behind this: thought-action fusion. It’s the belief that thinking something bad is almost the same as doing it, or that thinking it makes it more likely to happen. Studies have found that religiosity is linked to thought-action fusion in some groups (Rassin & Koster, 2003), and that in Christian samples especially, being more religious goes along with seeing bad thoughts as morally equal to bad actions (Siev & Cohen, 2007).
Now add in a teaching like “if you think it, you’ve already committed it in your heart.” For a brain that’s prone to OCD, that’s like pouring gasoline on a campfire. Every intrusive thought, which every human being has, becomes a sin that has to be fixed. Right now.
There is local research on this too. A study of 421 Latter-day Saints found that legalism, a rule-focused approach to faith, was linked to guilt and shame, and that scrupulosity fully explained that link (Allen, Wang, & Stokes, 2015). In plain English: the rules weren’t creating shame by themselves. The obsessive, scrupulous way of relating to those rules was. Another study of LDS adults found that scrupulosity helped explain why unhealthy perfectionism was tied to more depression and anxiety (Allen & Wang, 2014).
Notably, that same research found that religious commitment itself was linked to higher life satisfaction. I want to say that clearly. Faith is not the problem. Fear-based, high-control faith is a different story.
Okay. Let’s talk about the repentance process.
Many people I work with were taught a step-by-step process for repentance. The exact wording varies by church, but for many of my LDS clients, it sounds something like this:
Catholic clients often describe something similar: examine your conscience, feel contrition, confess, do penance, receive absolution.
For many people, this process is meaningful and healing. I’m not here to take that away from anyone.
But now look at the OCD cycle side by side:
| Repentance step | What it can become in scrupulosity |
|---|---|
| Recognize your sin | Obsession and checking. “Was that a sin? What about that? What about the thought I had an hour ago?” Endless mental review. |
| Feel godly sorrow | Anxiety spike and rumination. “Do I feel sorry enough? What if I’m faking it? What if God knows I’m not sincere?” |
| Confess | Compulsive confession and reassurance-seeking. Confessing the same thing again and again. Asking leaders or family, “Am I forgiven?” |
| Forsake the sin | Avoidance and thought suppression. Trying to never think the thought again, which makes it come back stronger. |
| Make restitution | Undoing rituals. Extra prayers, extra fasting, extra service, extra scripture to “cancel out” the thought. |
| Keep the commandments | Hypervigilance. Constantly scanning yourself for the next slip. The cycle resets. |
Do you see it? The structure is almost identical. A trigger, a spike of fear and guilt, a ritual to make it go away, a short window of relief, and then the doubt creeps back in.
Here’s the trap. For a person without OCD, repentance has an ending. You do the steps, you feel peace, you move on. For a person with scrupulosity, there is no ending, because the OCD brain keeps moving the finish line. Did I confess everything? Was my sorrow real? What if I forgot something? The process that was supposed to bring freedom becomes the cage.
And because it looks like righteousness from the outside, nobody stops to ask if you’re okay.
The good news? Scrupulosity is very treatable.
The gold-standard treatment for OCD, including scrupulosity, is Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP). In ERP, you slowly and safely practice facing the thoughts and situations that trigger your fear, without doing the compulsion. Over time, your brain learns that the anxiety rises and then falls on its own. You don’t need the ritual to survive it.
Researchers who specialize in scrupulosity say that, at its core, ERP for religious OCD works the same as ERP for any other kind of OCD. It just takes extra care around faith, prayer, and sometimes working alongside clergy when a client wants that (Siev, Huppert, & Zuckerman, 2017). A good therapist will never force you to give up your faith. The goal is to give you back your choices, not to make them for you.
And when religious trauma is part of the picture, it matters to treat the trauma too. Remember that study about the Absolution factor? Those same researchers found that people with trauma histories were more likely to be labeled “treatment resistant” (Pinciotti et al., 2026). That doesn’t mean they can’t get better. It means the trauma underneath needs attention, not just the compulsions on top.
So what does freedom look like? Sometimes it’s buying the gum without praying. Sometimes it’s letting an intrusive thought float by like a cloud instead of chasing it down. Sometimes it’s praying again, but this time because you want to, not because you’re terrified of what happens if you don’t. That’s the difference between faith and fear.
I practice in Arizona, and I work with a lot of people connected to Utah as well. Between LDS wards, Catholic parishes, and non-denominational churches across both states, I see scrupulosity more often than most people would guess. Many people don’t even know it has a name. They just think they’re “bad at repenting,” or that they’re more sinful than everyone else in the pew.
If you’re in Gilbert, Mesa, Chandler, Tempe, Queen Creek, or anywhere in Arizona or Utah, and you’re stuck in a loop of guilt, confession, and doubt that never seems to end, please hear this: you are not a bad person. You are not weak in faith. You may be dealing with OCD, and it is treatable.
If you want to understand the difference between everyday church hurt and something deeper, read our post on Religious Trauma vs. Church Hurt. And if you grew up never being taught how to sit with hard feelings, you might find yourself in How High-Control Religion Teaches Emotional Illiteracy. Emotional avoidance and compulsions are close cousins.
Intrusive thoughts are not sins. They’re a normal part of having a brain. Everyone has them. The difference is what we were taught to do with them.
Our team at Inner Compass Counseling currently has two clinicians with openings: Jessica Dawson, LPC and Ashley Kirkpatrick, LAC. Both work closely with clients navigating religious trauma and faith transitions across Arizona and Utah. You can view their schedules and book a session here.
Every clinician on our team is supervised or consulted by me directly. That means when you sit down with any member of our staff, even our newest clinicians, you also get the benefit of my years of experience with religious trauma, scrupulosity, and faith transitions. You are never getting “less than.” You are getting our whole team behind you.
You were never meant to live in a loop. You’re allowed to rest.

Want more posts like this on religious trauma, scrupulosity, and healing? Subscribe to our newsletter here.
designed by SEPTEMBER STUDIO
TERMS & CONDITIONS
PRIVACY POLICY
Copyright 2020 INNER COMPASS COUNSELING & CONSULTATION
@mellissaperrytherapy
633 E Ray Road
Gilbert, AZ 85296-4200
602-633-4496
Inner Compass is a licensed mental health haven in Gilbert, Arizona for individuals, couples, families, and teens who are navigating life’s transitions and trauma. Offering religious trauma therapy, trauma therapy, and EMDR therapy.
Inner Compass is a licensed mental health haven in Gilbert, Arizona for individuals, couples, families, and teens who are navigating life’s transitions and trauma.

Be the first to comment